Outraging modesty in India

Image

Image courtesy liora k 

All sexual crimes short of rape fall under the ambit of ‘Outraging the modesty of a woman’, under section 354 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. This particular law makes a lot of presumptions about how a woman is expected to behave, and has misogyny stamped all over it. It is not unusual for a court to examine the ‘character’ of a victim during trial in cases involving sexual assaults.

Modesty of the victim in a sexual assault is a non-issue when it comes to punishing the perpetrators; unfortunately, that is not a view shared by the Indian judiciary. This is a glaring oversight that needs to be corrected.

A woman of ‘loose’ character, who decides to file a complaint of sexual assault, may be laughed out of the police station, and her complaint may never see the light of day. Policemen are the first line of defense for the legal system, and many genuine cases get culled because of bad judgment by the Police. There have been several reported instances of women filing complaints of sexual assault being harassed by the policemen themselves.

Image

During a rally in New Delhi protesting crimes against women

A comprehensive overhaul of the legal system, especially regarding the laws governing crimes against women, is the need of the hour. Women deserve justice, and decadent laws that set out moral guidelines for women need to be scrapped. All women should be treated equally – a prostitute has the same claim to law and justice as a Christian nun. Rooting out prejudice against women will require revamping the laws to reflect the modern times.

The police need to be more sensitive when it comes to dealing with issues of women’s rights. Today, the high-handedness of policemen has created a paradoxical situation where the wolf guards the sheep. Several state governments have taken pro-active steps in the right direction, including setting up all-women police stations and creating dedicated women’s cells to deal with sexual crimes. Of course, most of them do not realize that these are band-aid solutions – real change requires a fundamental shift in the way judiciary treats women.

Islamic republics have shown us first hand, what oppression of women can do to a society.

Policy makers in India should realize that you can’t hold women down without staying down with them.

Advertisements

19 thoughts on “Outraging modesty in India

  1. They judge the victim in court here too… the defense is allowed to bring up all kinds of things from a woman’s past. We live in a sick world. Because it is mostly run by men… still.

  2. woah. that is SO true. but dont you think it is because of the image a woman has? she is already seen as someone inferior to men. she is discriminated because of her sex. how is she to be taken seriously in a male dominant society?

    • Education is an important tool. It is hard to repress an educated woman. Also, family. Children, both boys and girls need to be made aware of their responsibilities from an early age. I’ve always felt that misogyny has it’s roots in the home.

  3. Amazing and Thank you for writing which is quite good and best wishes always, and greetings. Kindness blossoms in your heart

  4. Loved the article Krishnan.. This is one of those things that is always in my mind. I don’t remember but there are few Bollywood movies where the women of so called are humiliated in the police station itself and their complains are unheard.

    Not only this I have read cases in the newspapers too that after a rape case in Delhi once, a protester was made fun by a police.
    In such cases where a woman will go? Who would give them justice. The laws therefore needs amendments from time to time.
    The prostitutes are women too and above all they are Human being. And it the prime duty of the saviors to treat all equally and value their human rights.

  5. Even in the US the victim is often blamed: “Well, she shouldn’t have been wearing that” or “she shouldn’t have gone there.” It’s so unfair, and yet we have so far to go still. But I understand it’s more horrific in India. Some of the stories I’ve read have left my heart heavy indeed.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s